Skip to content
Nonpartisan Voter Resource May 5 · Nov 3
Menu
All races
Safe R State House

House District 58

Johnson County / Greenwood-Whiteland -- Open Seat

The Candidates

House District 58 covers the western half of Johnson County in central Indiana, including parts of Greenwood, Whiteland, and New Whiteland. The seat is open because incumbent Michelle Davis is running for State Senate District 41, where she has Trump's endorsement against incumbent Greg Walker.

The Republican primary features three candidates with distinct profiles. Young has legislative experience and institutional knowledge but carries the baggage of a 2022 primary loss. Brickley has a compelling personal story -- 30-year law enforcement career, shot in the line of duty, Medal of Valor. Reed has the most important structural asset: a coordinated endorsement from Johnson County's Republican establishment, including the county prosecutor, a commissioner, a council member, and the largest city's council president, plus backing from Americans for Prosperity and Right to Life Indiana.

The Democratic primary offers a contrast between Sears -- a healthcare business CEO with policy depth and a decade running an autism center -- and Reingardt, a college student running on a Georgist land value taxation philosophy. Regardless of who wins the Democratic primary, the general election math is prohibitive. The Republican primary will determine who represents HD-58.

Why It Matters

A genuine open-seat scramble with five candidates across two primaries. The Republican winner effectively determines who represents this district. Reed's coordinated endorsement from Johnson County's Republican power structure -- county prosecutor, commissioner, council member, and Greenwood's council president -- makes him the candidate to beat.

Key Numbers

Outgoing Rep. Davis's 2024 general election margin 67.4%
Total candidates across both primaries 5
Republican primary candidates 3

Candidate Profiles

Sources

  1. 1. Indiana House of Representatives District 58 - Ballotpedia https://ballotpedia.org/Indiana_House_of_Representatives_District_58
  2. 2. State House District 58, Indiana - Statistical Atlas https://statisticalatlas.com/state-lower-legislative-district/Indiana/State-House-District-58/Overview
  3. 3. State House District 60, Indiana - Statistical Atlas https://statisticalatlas.com/state-lower-legislative-district/Indiana/State-House-District-60/Overview
  4. 4. Michelle Davis (Indiana) - Ballotpedia https://ballotpedia.org/Michelle_Davis_(Indiana)
  5. 5. John Young (Indiana) - Ballotpedia https://ballotpedia.org/John_Young_(Indiana)
  6. 6. Johnson County incumbent faces three Republican primary challengers https://www.thestatehousefile.com/politics/elections/johnson-county-incumbent-faces-three-republican-primary-challengers/article_0e57cade-bc32-11ec-99f4-5773f47f75bf.html
  7. 7. Former State Rep. John Young to run for House District 58 - Daily Journal https://dailyjournal.net/2025/09/17/former-state-rep-john-young-to-run-for-house-district-58/
  8. 8. Ed Brickley for House IN 58 https://edbrickley.com/
  9. 9. Ed Brickley Jr. - OVOU Profile https://ovou.com/ebrickley
  10. 10. John Reed for Indiana https://reedforindiana.com/
  11. 11. Indiana Baptist College dean seeking Davis' House seat - Daily Journal https://dailyjournal.net/2026/01/19/indiana-baptist-college-dean-seeking-davis-house-seat/
  12. 12. ACE - Autism Center for Enrichment: Meet the Team https://www.autismenrichment.com/meet-the-team.html
  13. 13. Indiana State House District 58 Democratic Primary Debate https://www.progressiveindiana.net/p/indiana-state-house-district-58-democratic
  14. 14. Michelle Hennessee Sears - Donate via ActBlue https://secure.actblue.com/donate/hennessee4in
  15. 15. Land Tax Reform for Better Cities and Agrarian Justice in Indiana https://thedailyrenter.com/2025/02/12/land-tax-reform-for-better-cities-and-agrarian-justice-in-indiana-an-open-letter-to-the-indiana-legislature/
  16. 16. Eric Reingardt, Author at The Indiana Commons https://theindianacommons.com/author/eric-reingardt/
  17. 17. Indiana House of Representatives District 60 - Ballotpedia https://ballotpedia.org/Indiana_House_of_Representatives_District_60
  18. 18. Peggy Mayfield - Ballotpedia https://ballotpedia.org/Peggy_Mayfield
  19. 19. Peggy Mayfield - Indiana House Republicans https://www.indianahouserepublicans.com/members/general/peggy-mayfield/
  20. 20. Peggy Mayfield Campaign - Biography https://www.peggymayfield.com/bio.html
  21. 21. WFYI 2024 Indiana State House - District 60 https://www.wfyi.org/2024-indiana-state-house-district-60
  22. 22. David Waters - Ballotpedia https://ballotpedia.org/David_Waters
  23. 23. David W. Waters - BallotReady https://www.ballotready.org/people/david-w-waters
  24. 24. Higgs announces leadership of expanded Indiana Rural Summit, Syczylo files as Democratic candidate for House District 60 https://www.wbiw.com/2026/02/05/higgs-announces-leadership-of-expanded-indiana-rural-summit-syczylo-files-as-democratic-candidate-for-house-district-60/
  25. 25. 'Who is holding them accountable?' Community concern as Google details plans for Morgan County data center - WTHR https://www.wthr.com/article/news/local/google-announces-new-550-acre-data-center-campus-in-morgan-county-mooresville-indiana/531-0157e288-481d-41b1-8ead-36202861a993
  26. 26. Stop the Data Center in Monrovia - Protect Our Community https://protectmorgancounty.org/